
I live across the street from a deer-infested forest, so naturally my little townhouse garden has seen their effects. Annuals, like the Iresine and sweet potato vine formally looking fabulous in pots on my back patio, were especially hard-hit.
The deer didn’t just eat my annuals, though. They napped in the middle of my perennial border. So when someone told me to try mounting CDs to scare them off, I figured I’d give it a try. I was told that they’d flash in the sun and spook the deer.
A little Googling yielded Buffalo-Niagara Gardening recommending this technique to keep both deer and rabbits away. They note that it “gives you a way to reuse old CD’s and DVD’s. You can also use aluminum foil pie plates in the same way.”
A winery uses it to keep both deer and birds away. (But I want the birds!)

I also found this video about the technique, seen in this still image.

I don’t have horizontal poles from which to hang CDs, so I decided to try attaching them to rebar, installed across the deer’s regular pathway from my neighbor’s back garden to mine. And it seems to have done the job because I haven’t seen a single deer there since! Also yay! They haven’t scared away the birds, which like to perch on top of the poles.

Since then, new neighbors installed a fence, which has kept deer away from their yard – the yard from which they wandered to my perennial bed/napping site. So recently I removed the CDs, but left the rebar (for another post coming soon). Photo taken this week.
Front Yard, too!

Photo by my neighbor Kathy Labukas
Of course the deer still live across the street from me and this season a Mama and her two babies roamed across our front yards every day.
In this photo taken from the street, my garden is behind the green poles, where wires hold vines and Mardi gras beads. I never saw deer in my front garden but deer scat doesn’t lie, and I found some along the path through my little pollinator garden.
The solution? More CDs, this time easily hung from the wires that were holding up the vines and beads. No more deer poop in my garden.
You are so right; CDs seem to help. I use the tall metal double spinners (Amazon) to keep the deer away from my hostas. Thank you for not writing : “cd’s” except in the quote. It is one of my peeves. I don’t know why so many people insist on ‘s when an s will do.. sigh. A retired librarian thanks you.
I guess I’m a librarian in spirit, as excess apostrophes are a peeve of mine, too.
Hi Susan, I’m glad the CDs are working for you in repelling deer. When I wrote the article for Buffalo-NiagaraGardening.com, our neighborhood didn’t have deer. A few weeks ago, two bucks and a deer were feasting in my backyard. I’m happy I kept all those CDs!
The CDs will work for a while, then the deer grow accustomed to them and you have to move on to something else. My daughter cuts up Irish spring bar soap and scatters it around. Works for now.
Fun that you didn’t want to scare the birds – we did that years ago to try to keep birds off our fruit.
(Hollow laughter)
Can only say lucky you. Lucky also that you don’t mind having a load of shiny CDs to catch your eye in the garden. I’d hate that. I do wonder if there will be a longer term benefit? Whether they will after a while have a chuckle to themselves as they say “does she think we’re stupid “? But I wish you luck.
But maybe they’re just stupid enough! About the shiny CDs, I agree as to my rustic-colored back garden. Though the weathered rebar fits in quite well there to my eyes. Where I’m okay with the look of CDs is in the front, where they’re hanging with Mardi gras beads and fun colors everywhere.
Believe you me, I’m going to give CDs a try.
I also wish you luck! Fencing is my only choice after trying EVERYTHING. I now have 8-12 deer in my yards several times a day, in the middle of Williamsville, including 3 bucks.
Gasp!!!
Sitting here reading your rant and some movement caught my eye. Four does moving through the yard. I’ve had good luck with Deer Away but it’s so expensive. And, difficult to find the concentrate.
How interesting to find a common tip actually does work! I don’t have much trouble with deer, but rabbits, voles, mice, possums, and other small critters do irritate me.