Guest Rant by Jennifer Smith
Many years ago, more than I want to admit, I was planting my first garden. I had one of every plant I could find, as one is apt to do when presented with nurseries’ amazing plant offerings. It was wonderfully overwhelming, the plant shopping, and in short order, my garden was overwhelming as well. One of each plant is not the way to design a garden. I was a gardener with no restraint, and it showed as the garden was a discombobulated collection of plants with no semblance of order, not even a timid nod to design. Over time I learned to plant in sweeping bands and groupings that take on natural organic shapes.Those first gardens were a bit of a visual disaster, but they were the best garden classroom I could ask for. If I had known good design principles when I first started gardening, how many plants would I have really gotten to know and understand in those early years in my tiny yard? Not many.

Jennifer’s new garden at her office, Wimberg Landscaping.
Today, I garden a very generous space at my office. When there are new plants, or new-to-me plants, that I want to try, my boss is likely to say “yes” to my request. It’s a perk of working for Wimberg Landscaping. One of my tasks is to plan, plant, and tend our extensive pollinator display garden. The garden is in its third year and I’m in love. There are sweeping bands of Solidago ‘Fireworks,’ generous stands of different native grasses, masses of Echinacea, and areas where plants are in more modest groupings of three. I use plants I learn of from the Cincinnati Zoo & Botanical Garden, or read about in books, and English garden magazines. At the shop I can see what happens when plants are left to their own devises. Will they become maintenance attention seekers or will they play nice with the other plants?

The Wimberg pollinator focal garden at Ault Park, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Experiencing such a garden is the best way I can coax those new to gardening or the natural gardening movement to swap part or perhaps even all of lawn, beds of ground cover, or stands of invasive honeysuckle for plants that are more beneficial to nature and more attractive. Seriously, how often has anyone waxed sentimental about their honeysuckle? But a generous stand of Echinacea in bloom or covered in goldfinches – now you really have something worth admiring. This is how I like to attract homeowners to more natural ways of landscaping, with beauty and a sense of awe.
I am not one to demonize gardeners. I may offer a bit a friendly scolding when I see a lazy design of the same old trees, shrubs, and ground covers, but it’s done in a way to break the garden conversational ice. To chastise or vilify someone for their plant selection only puts them on the defensive. And who wants to listen to anyone after they‘ve been scolded? Nor do I want to take on the role of landscape police. No, my way is gentler. A walk around our garden at the office or our company’s pollinator focal garden at Ault Park and the client can see what it’s like to garden for butterflies, for native bees, and for the birds. Most importantly, they fall in love with this style of gardening.

Asclepias tuberosa compelling one to continue down the path while also playing host to multiple pollinators.

A bumblebee on an Eryngium.
A photo of Little Bluestem is fine, but to see it in person, planted in a curve with a backdrop of Solidago in bloom, and able to run your fingers through their soft seed heads is how we sell the idea of planting for pollinators. To touch a plant, to see it intermingled with other plants, (what, no tidy rings of mulch around each plant?) to hear the crickets and the finches and to see the countless variety of bees and butterflies is how a new natural gardener is born. We entice with textures, colors, movement, scents, and sounds. I have that here in my office gardens, all that is grand along with a few cautionary tales. Mountain Mint, I take my hat off to you for your ability to draw in what I assume to be every single bee in a two-mile radius, but, my, how you spread!
Late summer and fall is the time to let our gardens show the beauty of planting for nature. When other traditional gardens are being put to bed, ours are still brimming with life and full of fabulous colors, blooms, textures, and architectural form. The natural garden is more than a riot of colorful blooms, it’s also winter habitat and food. And most importantly, if we want people to adopt this way of gardening, it’s a winter garden of immense interest. It’s a garden they will want to look at and explore, year-round. Can a lawn and obligatory shrubs draw us out on a cold winter morning to see how the frost settles on native grasses? The answer to that is “No.”
Jennifer Smith is a garden writer and photographer who works at Wimberg Landscaping. Jennifer specializes in pollinator gardens. She has created or adopted beautiful gardens in two of the city’s parks and at a retirement facility.
Thank you I like your kind of persuasion!
Thank you, Jessica.
But, truly, this is a scold, isn’t it?
No…she is actually making a point against those all or nothing gardeners who are unrealistic in their demands on how others should garden. There can be a balance with a blend of natives and non natives.
I don’t have any preoccupations about native or non native, I love honeysuckle and most of those plants too, I have a garden which blossoms into October and I still felt scolded. And a little patronised.
I felt the same way. Felt like I was being condescended to, but I don’t believe she meant to be.
Any reason why my reply to Jennifer’s post is now missing?
Thanks, Patrick
LOVE your approach!
Thanks, Pierre!
Indeed !
One quibble. Anyone who learned to love Japanese honeysuckle as a child is very likely to be sentimental about it. Invasive, yes. But also sweet-scented (as the more appropriate ones never seem to be).
As a hiker seeing bands of nothing but Japanese honeysuckle and knowing that it is preventing the next generation of trees from growing is enough for me to eradicate the honeysuckle.
Gorgeous gardens. Nothing like a great example to get people to change their minds and try something new.
Thank you!!
Good example of leading by example. Seeing the reality of a garden as part of a healthy ecosystem is gentle rebuke, a teachable moment.
Thank you! I think it’s easier to have our gardens speak for us, they do such a better job of telling the story of a balanced garden designed for us and for nature.
INCUDE natives in your garden. That is what I have tried to share in the last 20 years. I am a big supporter of natives, but at my advanced age of 83, I cannot tear out long established Camellias, for example, but am trying to eliminate plants that are on the invasive list for my area. Even Doug Tallamy suggests trying for 70%+ natives to help the environment, so I plan on taking care of my rather wild seven ac. as best I can. I enjoyed this post and often cringe when ranters list plants that, in my part of the country, are on the invasive list.
Seven acres! That sounds like a dream, and a lot of work. I try to add natives when I can, and those that if a client sees and wants, I know I can get easily. As more of us add native plants to our gardens we will see more native plants in our local shops … I hope! To replace a honeysuckle with a better shrub is a win. Swapping lawn for flowering plants a great win. As homeowners see more butterflies and bees, they will be drawn to more flowers and become more receptive to the idea of adding more native plants whenever possible.