The premise of my earlier story, about a rooftop sycamore that could not be iced, was misleading. A sycamore got iced, in that the tree turned out to be a cottonwood. Good news: the story, since then, has become richer. By coincidence, the tale of the abandoned 13-story Louisville Merchants & Cold Storage has taken on vibrant new life with a wealth of curious people and surprising fauna and flora.
Rose and I ran into David Levine at a party in the nearby Shelby Park neighborhood in late May, two weeks after the first story. David is a Louisville businessman and owner of Fleur de Flea, a popular 30,000 square foot warehouse full of vintage records, clothing, furniture, and well—you name it. The Fleur de Flea is a profoundly happy place. (Our visiting granddaughter confirmed, “I can spend hours in there.”)

Out of the blue
Rose mentioned the Ice Tower. David said he knew the Ice Tower well. He had been photographing nesting peregrine falcons in a window box the past few weeks. Fleur de Flea and the Ice Tower are separated by an elevated rail line and the south fork of Beargrass Creek.
Levine told me his friend Matt Weir had discovered the falcons ten years before. Matt is a sculptor who observes peregrines from his art studio on the ground floor of the Fleur de Flea. “The falcons were hard to miss.” Weir said, “They were intriguing to listen to and watch, and I was thrilled when I made out those white cheeks that look like sideburns. Peregrines were and are my favorite bird, but up until then I had never seen one before.” Weir notified Kentucky Fish and Wildlife, who installed a nesting box on the Ice Tower.

I needed to rope in Pam Spaulding
Pam is a gardening friend, retired Courier Journal photographer, and a devoted birder We met Levine a week later. As we were walking around the long east side perimeter of the Fleur de Flea, I noticed a fern adjacent to a leaky downspout. This was a head-scratcher. Pam employed the PictureThis phone app and came up with Pellaea atropurpurea. We didn’t know the purple cliffbrake fern, but we knew who would.
The three of us reached the ground floor vantage point from Matt Weir’s studio, adjacent to an elevated rail line. Levine’s narrow garden was tucked in between. “It’s my little version of New York’s Highline,” he told me. Fifty feet of railway right of way was planted with tassel flower larkspur, sweet peas, sunflowers, borage, and standing cypress.

David Levine
Standing in the shade beside the huge rollup door, we looked through Levine’s iPhone rigged to high-powered binoculars, focused on the peregrine falcon’s nest on the Ice Tower a thousand feet away.
Peregrines don’t nest at the Ice Tower every year
The peregrines were last here in 2024, but they live all year along the Ohio River. Pam said, “The falcons hang out in high places and when hungry, they watch for prey and protect their territory…They will bring food to the fledglings for a while, before teaching them how to catch food.” In acrobatic fashion, “they fly around the fledglings and drop a bird in the air for them to catch. The first year of their lives is the most dangerous until they become good hunters themselves. The rest of the year they loaf.”

“The three chicks are alert and waiting for a parent to bring food.”

“While the two falcon chicks, at left, clean food off each other’s face, the 3rd chick exercises its wings to get strong enough for flight.”

“The first chick takes flight for the first time. It’s probably a male because it’s noticeably smaller than its two siblings.” The other two chicks fledged over the following couple of days.”

“An adult flies with a lunch of pigeon.”
There are plenty of doves and pigeons to feed on. Peregrines, in addition, have been documented to feed on 400 bird species worldwide.
I found myself crouching over the kill, like a mantling hawk. My eyes turned quickly about, alert for the walking heads of men. Unconsciously I was imitating the movements of a hawk, as in some primitive ritual; the hunter becoming the thing he hunts. I looked into the wood. In a lair of shadow the peregrine was crouching, watching me, gripping the neck of a dead branch. We live in these days in the open, the same ecstatic fearful life. We shun men. We hate their suddenly uplifted arms, the insanity of their flailing gestures, their erratic scissoring gait, their aimless stumbling ways, the tombstone whiteness of their faces.
The Peregrine
–J.A. Baker

I got in touch with Leslie Pancratz
Leslie has planted and maintains the beautiful fern and woodland garden at Louisville’s Whitehall. She was eager to learn more about a hardy native Kentucky fern she’d known from research but had never seen. She brought her husband along. Mike Hayman is a former photographer colleague of Pam’s and now the senior director of TreesLouisville. Hayman mentioned that James Duffy, a real estate developer, one of the owners of the Ice Tower, lived two doors down.

Purple cliffbrake fern. Mike Hayman photo.
James Duffy, a tree lover in his own right, told me about the memory of a bur oak from his mother’s farm in Springfield, Kentucky. Hayman, who has a good grip on the availability of a wide variety of trees, helped his neighbor find a bur oak for his back yard.
The Ice Tower story was turning into a communion of the serendipitous
Duffy organized a gathering of this unusual congregation. He’d been to the mountain top—well, uh, the rooftop—many times.
A week later Mike Hayman, Pam Spaulding, James Duffy, Matt Weir, David Levine, and Kyle Jahn, owner of the adjacent Trellis Brewing, convened at basecamp to exchange ideas and prepare for the ascent to the 13th floor summit. The tree’s identity was up for grabs.

(L-R): MIke Hayman, Pam Spaulding, James Duffy, Matt Weir, David Levine, and Kyle Jahn. Allen Bush photo.
We talked about the discovery of the purple cliffbrake fern on the east side of the Fleur de Flea. There was a long green pattern, next to a leaky Ice Tower downspout. From a distance this looked like moss attached to cracks in the limestone brick mortar. But this was also a cliffbrake fern cascading 100 feet down the east side of the Ice Tower. Weir suspects that there could be something fundamental about the mortar mix, perhaps different from other limestone mortar mixes that proved advantageous for the Ice Tower and the Fleur de Flea. “The Ice Tower is a limestone cliff with seepage,” Hayman added.

Ray Cranfill’s Ferns and Fern Allies of Kentucky, 1980. Courtesy of Leslie Pancratz.

Kyle Jahn and James Duffy
Leslie Pancratz had emailed a few days before. “I return frequently to a list of ferns native to Jefferson County…I knew Pellaea (the purple cliffbrake) was on the list. Of the roughly 38 ferns native to Jefferson County, Whitehall grows 16…Although we’ve never had the opportunity to try Pellaea atrorpurpurea, I knew it was unlikely to ever happen. I had the impression that Pellaea would require conditions similar to Cheilanthes/Myriopteris which are difficult for us. We struggle to keep the walking fern going on the limestone wall!”
Ferncliff Distillery
Duffy mentioned that Ferncliff Distillery, begun in 1870, had once stood on the concrete pad where we were now standing. There are plans to relaunch Ferncliff Distillery one day. He also told us there had been once limestone cliffs, adjacent to the Southfork of Beargrass Creek, before the creek was channelized for storm water control and the railroad trestle was built. “There were cliffbrake ferns growing in cavities on those cliffs,” he said.
For years graffiti artists—both the talented and the useless—roamed the Ice Tower with spray paint. It was a popular teen hangout. “It seems all walks of life have visited the Ice Tower. Duffy, who is now 40, confessed. “I once hung out there.”


Duffy spent a few minutes opening the entrance barricades. Video cameras, monitored by a security company, are in the stairwell now that have put a stranglehold on teenagers, or anyone tempted to rustle falcons. Beware: Levine and Weir have got their eyes on you. Peregrines are Federally protected. They are no longer endangered but are protected under the Migratory Bird Treaty Act.
The group climbed to the top.
I waited at basecamp.
The trekkers returned from their expedition an hour later
Upon first entering the ground floor, Pam was astounded by the size of the huge supporting columns. The Ice Tower is durable despite its crumbling exterior. Duffy talked about more rooftop trees one day.

Kyle Jahn


David Levine and the cottonwood

Guardians of the peregrines: David Levine and Matt Weir
After coming down, Pam felt awestruck by nesting peregrines, cliffbrake ferns, the Ice Tower’s history, fleeting moments of joy, and the convergent path that brought curious people together whom she had not known a few weeks before.

Matt Weir

Pam compared the Ice Tower adventure to her three China trips in the early 2000s. (I was lucky to be with her on two of these seed and plant-hunting trips. Pam took thousands of photos.) She said the feeling of the Ice Tower experience was comparable to going out, on a good day, in rural Sichuan.
After observing peregrines for several weeks, I asked Pam to describe the flight of peregrines.
Peregrines don’t spend long periods gliding like hawks or vultures. They don’t flap like smaller birds either. Their flight from one building to another is usually a series of a few quick, powerful wingbeats followed by a short glide—repeated—over and over. They patrol their territory and give the impression of being completely in command and constantly alert. Think of the rippling muscles of a leopard even when it is slowly walking. You sense restrained power and pent-up energy. I’m in awe of those birds.”
You never know what’s around the corner. Keep your eyes peeled.
All photos, except where noted, are courtesy of Pam Spaulding.
Fascinating! And great teamwork!
I loved this. Love how it brought people together !
Fun read, great stuff.
This is great! I know Dave but I didn’t know about his little mini garden. Gonna have to check that out. This is a wonderful story. It’s amazing how plants and animals can bring people together to experience nature and make new friends at the same time. Keep up your great stories Allen!
Too many decades have passed, since reading an article such as this.
Thank you, Godspeed.
What a wonderful story. Adventure, beauty, history … it’s got it all! Hi to James Duffy, who was on the LSC Green Building & Infrastructure Action Team with me.
The Congress for New Urbanism did a legacy project about 7 years ago along the South Fork of Beargrass. I wish we had known about the ferns and falcons then
I love following your articles across links and years. You have a real talent for taking your readers along with you!