Most of the fast-spreading plants in my garden arrived as local weeds. Here they are (plus a couple that I planted deliberately) and how I’m dealing with them.
Creeping Jenny as potentially harmful, or a great garden plant

Creeping Jenny in my back yard, in spots where a taller plant wouldn’t work – beneath a hydrangea, on top of a wood-chip path, and between flagstones.
My recent post extolling the eye-popping qualities of chartreuse foliage, I showed off the Creeping Jenny growing between my flagstones and promised to research whether they’re invasive in my area and if so, what I should do about them in my garden. Here’s what I learned.
It’s not on Maryland’s invasive plant list, even as an additional plant considered.
Next, how else to determine if it could cause harm on this site?
But digging deeper, is there any way this common local weed could harm a nearby natural area? Since it spreads only by runner and would have to cross the street to get to a natural area (which itself is covered with invasives at the ground level), I say no.
But is it too thuggish for my garden? Not at first but lately it’s gained steam and I noticed it overpowering the groundcover Sedums that I want to keep alive, so I’m removing them from around the Sedums. That’s the only plant that’s in harm’s way (so far).
I do love Creeping Jenny’s color and its extremely short stature, enabling it to be grown right under shrubs without blocking air or light. And between flagstones, no other plant is short enough, and mulches just wash down the slop during heavy rains.
And unlike my Sedum, I can step on Creeping Jenny, which I do almost daily, without it breaking off.
Ajuga – another one that’s slow to attack

For 10 years there was just one little patch of Ajuga (planted by a previous owner) amidst a mass of Packera aurea. But this year I noticed the patch was much bigger, having killed some nearby Packera, so it has to go! (Easier said than done; it’ll take years to remove all the sneaky bits.) I did move some to a safer spot around shrubs.
Groundcover comfrey – super-spreading pollinator magnet
This ground cover comfrey, a passalong plant from a nearby woodland garden, immediately took off in mine, and I’ve loved watching bees feed on it for its long bloom period. I also loved how fast it filled in – until it became clear it would quickly cover the whole border, and maybe the whole garden. Above you see one of the borders it was taking over. I removed all but the patch on the right far.
Still this super-spreader is a plant I’ll keep – within bounds. Not only do bees love it; it’s beautiful and completely block out any new weeds. It’s truly one of the most effective groundcovers I’ve ever seen, and it’s happy in shade.
Black-eyed Susans – the gift that keeps on giving
Rudbeckia hirta is my state flower, it blooms for a long time, is super-cheerful, and will fill a bed or border in no time. In fact, I’ve often recommended that new, empty gardens be filled in with passalong black-eyed Susans – to be edited out as other plants are added and mature.
That’s what happened here in my front yard after I removed the horrible arborvitae hedge and had lots of new space to fill. I used all the Susans I could find, but removed all but one group as I gradually increased diversity in the border. (I noticed very few insects visiting them, anyway.)
Mexican evening primrose and Rose Campion can spread all they want

I love these air-borne weeds and to them I say “More, please!” But they come and go on their own accord.
Bronze fennel – another hit with butterflies and hummingbirds

Growing alongside a Major Wheeler coral honeysuckle, the hummers can’t resist stopping! So I’m okay with fennel’s promiscuous self-seeding in my border;
Joe Pye Weed and Wood Aster seem adapted to each other’s spread
I grow ‘Little Joe’ Joe Pye Weed and wood aster together in this small border and while they both spread, it’s seemingly not to the detriment of the other. It must help that they grow sequentially – the wood aster emerging early and the Joe Pye weeks later.
But you’re going to hate this next one – periwinkle
Finally, I’ll mention one plant that IS on Maryland’s invasive plant list – periwinkle, or vinca minor. As of 2017, sellers must display a “Tier 2 sign” about its invasiveness.

Admittedly, I DID once defend periwinkle in places where it can’t escape – like in this spot between my garden and parking lot, surrounded by concrete and asphalt. It can’t climb trees, so the tree and the shrubs I planted there are safe. (Curiously, in the Maryland neighborhoods where I’ve gardened, the usual complaint about periwinkle is that it doesn’t spread enough.)
But in garden beds it’s a very different story! I complained in this post about its stealth nature, having not spread much my first 8 years here until suddenly it’s overtaken some plants I want to keep. Now years after deciding it had to go, I’m still finding little bits of the stuff.
Periwinkle… It does cover ground.. and doesn’t climb trees and shrubs like grrr. ivy. I am constantly pulling up ivy and probably will be found someday, dead in the stuff. I call it ivy murder. And I fear the ivy is the murderer. Packasandra , sp? is probably better but at age 78, It’s too late for me to plant. I just keep pulling ivy up and off trees. My latest enemy is clover. Anyone know how to get rid of it? I also find violets very evasive. And of late , clematis!!! I love clematis but am finding it everywhere!! I know I didn’t plant it there. or there or there!!!
At about age 70, I planted pachysandra. At age 75, I’m pulling it up out of my adjacent pea gravel walks and regretting planting it. The periwinkle with the unusual and beautiful magenta blooms that I planted in a border bed about 5 short years ago is strangling a small hydrangea, choking out coneflowers and native Joe Pye weed and invading the same pea gravel walk. It’s in a fight to the death with the liriope along the walk. I’m just going to have to sit by with a cup of tea and see which one wins, as I’m afraid they are both beyond the strength of my arthritic hands now to dispatch.
I’ve tried vinca minor as my front yard ground cover in San Francisco and Oakland. Never covered the ground in either location. Always more oxalis than vinca. Now my ground cover is fragaria (strawberry plant). It’s a cultivar of a plant that is native in California. It’s said to do well in sandy soil. I do not have sandy soil. Very successful. Few weeds can compee with it. I tried ajuga for the first time last year. Lasted about 2 months. Don’t plan to try it again.
What’s my point? Plant behavior varies widely, because it depends mostly on specific growing conditions, e.g.., light, soil, moisture, climate, etc. That’s why so much of the conversation about “invasiveness” is nonsense because what is invasive in one place is not invasive in another. Trial and error is the best strategy in the garden, IMO.
Excellent points.
I’d like to add another thug to your list, Susan: houttuynia cordata, also known as chameleon plant. It’s very pretty, but once it gains a foothold it’s extremely difficult to eliminate, spreading by underground runners.
And it smells bad! At least the ones that I planted have been mostly restricted to the dry shade, maple root crowded bed I started it in.
And the lovely pink and green variegated colors that attracted me disappear as the plants get older and bigger, leaving a boring meh green.
Among your thugs only vinca is soreading in our surrounding woods -A problem but almost insignificant compared to the monsters: wisteria and bamboo which are destroying acres of our woodlands – at high speed, strangling trees and arresting natural forest regeneration.
Your borders are gorgeous and I need to find some of the comfrey you mentioned. As a long-time gardener (sounds better than “old”), with 25 acres to spread out in, I welcomed enthusiastic reproducers. In my youthful enthusiasm, I planted English ivy, burning bush, gooseneck loosestrife, creeping Jenny, hellebores, lily-of-the valley, ajuga, and many more thugs. I don’t regret the forget-me-nots or the foxgloves and columbine that volunteer in large numbers, but the Japanese wisteria that I intentionally planted and the bittersweet that I inadvertantly sowed when I tossed dried fall decorative sprays into the woods are my biggest banes. They have already brought down trees, and I fear what will happen when I’m gone and can no longer pull up the marauding vines that appear in unexpected places. I have mostly eradidicated the burning bush and the ivy is gone, but I’m afraid my other mistakes will long outlive me. As they say, “too soon old, too late smart”!
Interesting about the fennel…I’ve never seen a hummingbird near mine. Joe Pye is everywhere, I constantly pull it up…same with heliopsis. And that darn lily of the valley! I will never get rid of it, and it has spread all over the place. I agree with you about rose campion.
Sadly, I cannot get rose campion to survive, much less grow. And while I have lots og Joe Pye, the groundhogs and deer think it’s their special treat. They give it the Chelsea chop all Spring and summer.
Sadly, I cannot get rose campion to survive, much less grow. And while I have lots of Joe Pye, the groundhogs and deer think it’s their special treat. They give it the Chelsea chop all Spring and summer.
I have deep shade under a mature copper beech tree (50+ ft tall) between two houses that are also at least 40ft tall. The “soil” is basically just sand and it floods when it rains as the runoff between the two trees pools there for a day or two before it soaks in. Hardly any weeds will grow there. I did get a few clumps of vinca from a local person off CL five years ago and they’re only just barely alive–they’re smaller than when I got them. Still looking for something invasive enough to grow in this spot.
I’ve seen people post about growing in “full shade” on IG and their video was just the north side of a small 5ft fence, otherwise not shaded by house or tree, with full overhead sun. I could see how “thug” plants would get a reputation for bad behavior in such “full shade.”
I would love to hear about lily-of-the-valley, which is taking over my small yard. It moves very quickly, and anything in its way disappears. It has to be pulled out by the roots. If anyone has had any experience with getting rid of it, please let me know!
My neighbor used to have lily-of-the-valley and now I’ll always have some. Hate it.
Meanwhile here in Australia I have five treasured corms of lily of the valley that I am fighting to keep alive. It was my mother’s favourite flower; scarce, finicky, and precious. It really is a matter of finding the right plant for the right place.
I spent one or two summers removing several large beds (the smallest was about 20ft x 15ft) each solidly full of lily of the valley, pachysandra or vinca. I hacked away at them with a Truper hand digger. (It’s got a claw on one side, is extremely beefy, and really worked well.) Just yanked up gobs and gobs of root masses and tossed them into contractor bags.
It’s been maybe 6 years now? They’re all basically eradicated. I think I’ve pulled maybe a handful of lily of of valley plants in all that time. The trick for me was digging down about 6 inches. Get below the root mass and you can pull them up, especially if they’re densely matted like mine were. That’s what worked for me!
Lilly of the valley. Smells so good. So pretty. Want to have just a tiny patch of them. Ha.
I have planted Antennia neglecta, Field Pussytoes between large step stones. The flowers are about 3 inches tall and bloom very early. I have no trouble walking over the flowers but you could cut down the dead flowers if they get in your way. It’s a host plant for the American Painted Lady Butterfly. It spreads fairly quickly and has solved my weed problem between step stones in sunny areas. Another one I grow in sun is Herniaria glabra , Rupturewort and bonus, it’s evergreen!
Here in the UK I’ve tried to grow Joe Pye weed in a border but it doesn’t come back! Have vinca but it seems to be under control. Not a fan of creeping jenny (sounds like a primary school sneak) as I don’t care for the yellow flowers but it creeps in everywhere. Woodruff is taking hold in shady places. Have I made a mistake with this currently trendy ground cover plant?
Lily of the valley.. love it. Brought some to Virginia from my childhood home in Nebraska but it got covered when we had a huge brick wall and gates added. It was a favourite flower of many famous people who had it put on their caskets. Jackie K. Onassis and Audrey Hepburn for two. You have inspired me to get some and plant it. It likes north side.
I’ve found that Sweet Woodruff, once established, creeps everywhere- loving both sun and shade – into my yarrow, rudbeckia, daisy’s etc etc etc. I love it BUT it is definitely over-friendly!
I limb up my roses to keep the leaves from being in the dirt, thus attracting disease and little buggers. It works, but I wasn’t fond of the bare look under my roses. I planted sweet woodruff, just a little bit, and let it roam under the roses. It’s a beautiful addition to this area of the garden. If it seems a bit too much, it’s easy to pull up. I planted it four years ago and have kept it in check. It’s pretty and I love it.
I’m in Maryland zone seven Ish.I love comfrey and use it as green mulch however it needs to be contained. I continue to remove Lily of the valley, even though I have fond memories of its delicate fragrance as a child.
I inherited the autumn Clematis (with its lovely fragrance) and yet I am removing it wherever I find it as it is a robust volunteer. I continue to remove mustard garlic, and bittersweet and let the violets, strawberries, creeping Jenny and anenome canadensis fill in until they are in the way.
My bane of existence appears to be bindweed. At this moment, it seems to be only in one area. However, it may outlive me.
This spring I have pulled out about a hundred wheelbarrow loads of creeping speedwell. I think when I turn my back fifty more plants pop out every hour. I thought I had it somewhat controlled a month ago and then I went out of town for a week the beginning of May. Oh my, I was overwhelmed by it when I got home. I’m barely getting the upper hand on it the last few days. I’m hoping now that a few of my self-seeders can get some sun and air without the speedwell choking them, they’ll help me fight it all.
I grow the low comfrey and it provides nectar from February to June, it clothes under the apple trees and I love it. However Trachystemon orientalist beats it every time and is dense and overwhelming. Red campion is the weed I love and it is all through my rose borders blending beautifully with the pinks, reds and cream.
The most invasive plant I am currently dealing with here in N Wales is the chocolate vine Akebia quinata which spans lawns to invade other beds, suffocates shrubs and I am having difficulty locating one of my taps due to the swathes round the post.