I have been piddling along on the Lenten rose slow lane for years. My garden is not well stocked with new breeding. Possession of my old hellebores—with downward facing flowers, may be considered a deadly gardening sin, but only because the evidence points to being slothful and contrary. Though I grow two strains of colorful erectile-functioning single Lenten roses purchased long ago, few friends stop to point them out as the bee’s knees. No one has challenged me and asked, “Why don’t you grow more upward facing or double hellebores?”

Common Lenten roses. What’s not to like?
The indisputable truth… I have never seen any Lenten rose that didn’t look good floating in a shallow bowl of water.
“I know, everyone does it. But it is a wow!”
Anne Wareham

Pine Knot’s floaters. Photo courtesy of Pine Knot.
You can float all of them whether they are the priciest newcomers or 50-year-old hangdog, Helleborus x hybridus passalongs from granny’s overgrown garden. And, yes, a few doubles could add a dimension—just don’t overdo it.
Great Dixter’s Christopher Lloyd jokingly called the whole lot: “hell-BORES.”
My heart bleeds
Heaven forbid every pendulous flowering plant be doomed by breeders.
Does a hanging bleeding heart (Dicentra spectablis) beg for erectile improvement? Or a fuchsia or a snowdrop (Galanthus)?
Mary Vaananen and Abi Rennekamp held each of my hands this Lenten season. I was trying to make sense of fashionable erectile functioning (upward or outward facing flowers). They sent photos of floating hellebores that included “new and improved” cultivars. I admit…Their floaters were beautiful.

Mary Vaananen’s hellebore floaters

Abi Rennekamp’s hellebore floaters
Mary, a popular Guest Ranter, said, “I think Lenten roses are the most amazing plants. Tough as nails, with gorgeous blooms that withstand freezing temps. The exquisiteness of the hellebore flower seems magnified by the usually brown/gray wintery backdrop of the garden. They are so welcome as our hunger for spring and green and warmth peaks.”
Where have I been all these years?
Mary and Abi’s photos made me feel as if I had been in a cloistered monastery for half a lifetime, putzing around alone with a deck half full of hellebores.
Abi came out to the farm a few weeks ago and brought the sweetest small vase of flowers that included littler daffodils, a pinkish-red Corydalis and a long-stalked cut bloom of a semi-double Lenten Rose. ‘Peppermint Ice’ had not been stripped of its dangling charm.

‘Peppermint Ice’
As an object of art, Abi also schooled me on the scope of 21st century hellebore breeding, and then demonstrated the possibilities by sending me a Derletzwolf Instagram photo. His extraordinary Lenten rose bouquet was reminiscent of the richness and mood of Rachel Ruysch (1664-1750), the “Grand Dame” of Dutch floral painting.
I can’t remember my last Lenten rose purchase
Years ago, I seem to recall, I bought a white with burgundy splashes from my friends Judith and Dick Tyler at Pine Knot Farms in Virginia. The yellows came from the legendary English hellebore breeder Elizabeth Strangman. The darkest of dark ones may have come from the well-known O’Byrnes in Oregon.

My hellebore floaters from three “improved” hellebore strains

Indispensable, but available only on Kindle. You may find used books for sale online.
Dick Tyler of Pine Knot Farms looked at photos of these and said there was no way to tell where they had come from.
There is little doubt, the publication of Hellebores—A Comprehensive Guide, published in 2006, accelerated the fascination of every backyard Gregor Mendel, willing to shun peas for Lenten roses. The book co-authored by Judith Tyler and C. Colston Burrell includes a botanic and historic accounting of hellebores, with details about influencers from herbalist John Gerard (1545-1612) to gardeners, botanists and breeders of the current era. Lots of geeky morphology, a thorough accounting of hellebores species, simple how-to wisdom and propagation advice. I should have paid closer attention to the their breeding tips.
I got on board with Helleborus x hybridus thirty ago, sort of. Derailment never happened, but there was a long delay at the station.

Pine Knot’s best yellows. Photo courtesy of Pine Knot.
Patience has its virtues
Remarkably, I had not seen any results of my open-pollinated yellow strain cross until ten days ago. A few years ago, I gave two of my seedlings from my upward facing plants to Mike Rogers, my friend and neighbor. He showed me the results ten days ago. One was a fine yellow, the other a pale yellow with red splashes. My first flowering yellow seedlings in 30 years!
Clearly, I have been asleep at the wheel, relying on dumb luck, unable to steer yellow or black-flowering seedlings in any direction. Rose and I had gotten sidetracked with scree plants, hundreds of perennials, a vegetable garden, planting hundreds of trees, and thousands of daffodils. Hellebores got the short end of the stick.

Dark flowering Lenten rose
Back in Salvisa, the whites with a burgundy splash have been productive. Helleborus x hyrbidus can be a spreader. (To be clear: I am talking about an in-house self-seeding machine.)
Lenten roses (Helleborus x hyrbidus ) often lacks self-control.
Profligacy has its benefits
And you can save a hefty sum.
I have dozens of clumps of white hellebores with burgundy splashes, and 10,000 more waiting in the wings if you count the flood of new seedlings every year.
And I do mean flood…(We had a previous flood in February. I am becoming a sump pump expert with help from Ben Miller, a friend, who helped renovate our house thirteen years ago. Ben replaced a dead pump a day before the heavy rains set in and inspected downspouts and drain pipes.)

A little surreal. Flooded daffodils and Canadian geese along the Salt River last weekend.
Hell-YEAH, not hell-BORES, when the floodwaters rose last week. We had 10 +” of rain over four days.

Late-blooming daffodils survived the flood. So did the barn and house.
Sharpen your trowel and be ready to release the overflow before blooms fade. Help your Lenten rose refugees find a new garden sanctuary before the river rises again.
To paraphrase the Gospel of Luke: To whom thousands of Lenten rose seedlings are gifted, much is expected.
If you don’t have your own seed-producing plants of Lenten rose, or your friends with hellebores are miserly, you can order fresh Helleborus x hybridus seeds from Jelitto Perennial Seeds for delivery this summer. Sow them in a garden bed ASAP upon receipt and mark where you put them. Hellebore seeds will need a warm period, mimicking the natural outdoor temperatures of summer and fall, followed by a cold, winter period. Germination commences in mid-late March in central Kentucky.

Helleborus x hybridus seed pod. Mary Vaananen photo.
Whenever I dig a handful of seedlings from for friends, I am met with bewilderment. “You expect these puny white roots to live?” I am stern. “Yes, plant them as soon as you get home. These little seedlings are incredibly tough and are more difficult to transplant, with longer roots, when the first true leaves appear.”

Hellebore seedlings

Hellebore seedlings ready for transplanting on April 5, 2025
My memory bank
Thousands of Latin names for genus and species can still be dredged up, but my bank vault door got slammed on cultivar names a while ago. I remember my best childhood friend’s 1960 home phone number, but I draw a blank if you ask me to name a single new hellebore cultivar in the last ten years. Or the names of cultivars of echinaceas and heucheras for that matter, though I have grown a few of each.
New plants are introduced annually with a flourish. (Guilty as charged: I wrote catalog pomp for nearly 40 years.)
Even I am not immune to bravado, but I am more patient.
Plus, I have a home-grown deal that is hard to beat.
Every year I sow perennial seeds from Jelitto Perennial Seeds and the North American Rock Garden Society (NARGS). Keys to the Jelitto seed vault are at my disposal. (I was gifted free seeds when I retired from Jelitto in 2017 after 22 years on the happy seed trail with this great seed company.) And the annual NARGS seed exchange pushes the range of my possibilities, as well as failures, in our hot and humid summers, and cold and wet winters.

Catalog shopping has always been enjoyable, but I rely more now on word of mouth or being seduced when I see a new plant in a friend’s garden or a local garden center.
There was a lot of catching up to do from years past
Pine Knot’s Dick Tyler and I talked for an hour last week a few days before heavy rains set in. We caught up on kids, grandkids and old friends. I go way back with Dick and his late wife Judith. No one laughed as easily and as well as they did. They grew a wonderful family business, specializing in hellebores, now run by Brian Byers, a talented horticulturist who came to Pine Knot one week after graduating with a degree in horticulture from North Carolina State University in 2016. He took over the nursery reins in 2023.
Now 81, Dick lives on the Clarksville, Virginia, farm that has been cultivated by Judith’s family for six generations—seven generations if you count the grandkids.
Dick Tyler’s soft-spoken enthusiasm for hellebores is convincing
As we talked, I picked up on his unwavering devotion to a single genus. Not only for the breeding potential of Lenten roses (Helleborus x hybridus) but Christmas roses, stinking hellebores and interspecies hybrids—and for the love of wild species that extend from Southern and Central Europe (Spain, France and Germany and the Balkans) to the Mediterranean (Italy and Greece) to Turkey and the Caucasus. Will McLewin, the British plant explorer and hellebore expert, led Dick, Judith and Colston Burrell to study and photograph the hellebore-rich Balkans, in preparation for their book.
We talked about my poke-along yellow hellebore hybrids. Mine seldom set seed. Dick and Judith had long done hand pollination of their best yellow hybrids, and their controlled hellebore crosses are still made in screened greenhouses. Dick said Pine Knot’s yellow Lenten roses are not shy about setting viable seed.
We now know who the “hell-BORE” is
Dick didn’t scold me for my Lenten rose shortcomings or my leave of absence from Pine Knot’s winter hellebore open houses, the past three decades.

Our hellebores on their way to the Gulf of Mexico after four days of rain
Flood waters receded.
It didn’t take long to come to my senses.
The sun came out and I went online and fell in love again at Pine Knot Farms.
Hell-BORES no more.
There’s a lot to love.
I bought a hellebore over 30 years ago at the end of the season at a now defunct nursery. I think it was a dollar at most. Very tight budget back then. It is the common one. I think I have it in three locations now. Not the crazy spreader. Maybe that “first it sleeps,then creeps, then leaps” is in decades, not years for it.
Tibs, I am easily converted and a covetous sort by nature.My eyes are now wide open to newer hellebores, but I will always love the common ones.
“Possession of my old hellebores—with downward facing flowers, may be considered a deadly gardening sin, but only because the evidence points to being slothful and contrary.” There’s a lot of news (for me) packed in that short sentence. Right now my backyard is full of masses of hellebores, and they are bringing me much joy as they always do. I’ve always suspected they weren’t the favorite of serious, which I’m not, gardeners but I never understood that their presence in my garden meant that I was slothful and contrary. I confess to both. And now I think I’m even more proud of my big patch of hardy, carefree, reliable plants. Because I’m contrary!
Pam, here’s to joy contrariness. Congratulations on your big patch.
I’ve failed miserably with hellebore in Texas, but your white & raspberry ones are tempting. I’ll bet I could find a favorable spot in the garden on Poplar Street. Glad you & Rose & Rufus are safe and sound after all the nasty weather.
Jenny, looking forward to seeing you when you are next in Mercer County. I believe we can fix you up with hellebore seedlings.
Great article Allen I’m afraid I have let the hellebores get out of hand in my garden but they give a ‘big bang for their buck’! They are evergreen in deep shade (which there aren’t that many evergreens that thrive in shade), deer don’t bother them, and they bloom in so many variations – what isn’t there to like?
Abi, you, Mary V. and Dick Tyler turned my head around. Thank you.
I love the hellebores. I have couple of 20+ year old clumps. I occasionally dig a start from the side of the clumps but I love the massiveness of them. And, the seedlings. Which I covet. And, I disperse the seeds in the blank spots in my garden. They are a great cut flower in January when the obnoxious holiday decor has come down and I’m into my more minimalist mood. The subdued colors are perfect.
My favorite hellebore garden is on a hill, next to my front door. Our early spring/late winter weather is very rainy and grey so I love seeing them every time i run from the car to the door of the house. And, the hill means that I see their faces even if they are not upward facing. Plus, the greenery all summer is lush and doesn’t require any water here once established. The only hellebores that I don’t love are the very dark ones that get lost in the garden. But, I still have a few and appreciate their offspring seedlings!
You’ve painted a pretty picture, Eileen. Indoors and out.
I have been growing Hellebores for about 10 years, since I first saw them at the Burpee home garden in Pennsylvania. I buy some new ones each year from Pine Knot. It is unfortunate that it is no longer at the American Horticulture Society’s Spring Sale at River Farm in Alexandria, Virginia. I bought this years batch on-line and they are doing well.
I acquired my first Hellebore plant at our food co-op’s annual plant exchange many years ago. It took a few years to flower and decide my bed was suitable to its needs. This felt like a huge win for me as they continue to bloom and spread and give me great pleasure beneath our huge Black Walnut tree!
Rebecca, you’ve provided proof of the virtue of patience coupled with a mighty black walnut. Congratulations.
I have a lovely patch of them outside my front door. Unfortunately, the tree they are under has died and is being cut down. They won’t take too kindly to full sun here in the SE corner of VA. I’ll be giving a lot of them away, reminding people to be patient as they don’t like being transplanted.
I agree with Jim D. but would note. Some of my Lenten roses have a lot of afternoon sun. They’re fine unless there are prolonged droughts. The leaves will lie down and let me know that they need a drink.
I started out with a batch of seedlings gifted to me from the gardener @ Paca House in Annapolis, MD. Since then I have expanded to easily 500-plus plants. A lot of them are on a fairly steep bank and I get seedlings all over in my grassy walk by that bank. I let them go until the second, sometimes the third year. (I am not fussy either). Then I take them all up, usually in late March or early April. I just go in with a shovel, hack, slash and claw. When I get a flat full I pot ’em up. Then I repeat the process. The ones that have bloomed, I vet. Some I keep, and some I pot up into gallon pots. I have a pickup truck and get a cubic yard of soil from a nearby nursery. It has a lot of clay but hellebores love clay. The seedlings that have not bloomed I sort and pot up into gallons or 4″ pots, as needed. Then I go to several plant sales, usually to benefit a church or garden club
I believe in hellebores and want to spread them around. I price them cheaply– you can always find free pots, and the earth is my only expense.
And fool that I am, I go down to Pine Knot almost every year and get some of their seedling pots of various strains. These are a gamble, because you’ll never know, until they bloom, exactly what you have, but the anticipation is fun and I have never gotten an also-ran.
Jim, I am impressed. I admire your hard work and willingness to share your bounty for the benefit of others. I haven’t been to a Pine Knot winter open house in years, but I may have the hellebore bug-again. A trip to Clarksville, VA might be in the cards.
Jim again. A P.S. to Greg– don’t worry that your tree was cut down. I’ve seen hellebores lined out in crappy soil in full sun and happy as clams.
A week or two ago I ran across an article on Hellebores that gave me pause. I was particularly interested because I garden in northern Wisconsin (used to be Zone 3, now Zone 4A), and Hellebores haven’t been very prolific here — or sometimes, even enduring. I planted one two summers ago to test again, and it wintered over, so I planted a couple more last spring. We’ll see if they come back and how they do. For some locales, though, the article warns that they border on being invasive: https://www.nurturenativenature.com/post/in-my-yard-hellebores-are-pernicious-weeds. I definitely don’t want them to be seeding all over my garden or into the woods here.
Good question, Julie. I would urge caution if you feel any unease with Helleborus x hybridus. As I mentioned, the Lenten rose is a notorious self-sower. From that perspective alone, weeding WILL be required. Seeds are flung only a short distance and are moved around by ants, attracted to sweet-tasting elaiosome on the seed coat. The ants don’t move seeds far. And, in my garden in central Kentucky, I have seldom found seedlings more than a few feet away. (Seeds of the stinking hellebore (Helleborus foetidus) seem to move farther. I’m not sure why?) The native touch-me-not, Impatiens capensis, however beautiful and attractive to hummingbirds, is much more aggressive seeder and can be a weedy garden nuisance but is neither invasive nor displaces other plants. Lenten rose seedlings can be thuggish, so are not maintenance free. Furthermore, all hellebore parts are poisonous. I don’t know anyone who has been poisoned but I know gardeners who have suffered dermatitis when cutting back old foliage. (Gloves would be recommended.) There is no place where Helleborus x hybridus is labeled as invasive that I am aware of. Planting hellebores is discouraged in Australia and New Zealand. So, if you’re worried, or bothered about the potential for invasiveness, or that Helleborus x hybridus has no ecological benefit, then I wouldn’t hesitate to remove your Lenten roses.
The link you sent had information that does not collate with my experience in Kentucky. I’m not aware of hellebores spreading by rhizomes, but I could be proved wrong; they are not disease resistant (“Black death” is a threat; and they sulk badly for me in Kentucky’s hot afternoon sun.
Thank you for your thorough response, Allen. Very interesting about the ants! I didn’t know about the dermatitis either — and luckily hadn’t found that out the hard way. I love the leaves as much as the flowers, so I’ve wanted to try them again, and when I saw a robust H. ‘Walberton’s ® Rosemary’ (or ‘Walhero’) clump at a local greenhouse, I couldn’t resist. Coincidentally, some of the online descriptions say it is sterile, but I haven’t found anything definitive on that — yet. Hans Hansen mentions that cultivar in his article about new and improved hellebores in a recent Fine Gardening, “early spring” issue 222, and doesn’t say anything about it being sterile, though he does say that the FrostKiss ® series is. ‘Course, that wouldn’t be an improvement for those who find the seeding to be a bonus.
What a great article, Allen. It’s so nice to hear enthusiasm for hellebores. There are so many wonderful ones now. Great breeding has been going on. Pine Knot has so many good colors. I always fall for the black ones and picotees. Some of the Ice and Roses hybrids have great color that really last and they bloom earlier than most. A long season with them. Dick and Judith and Cole’s book is thorough and wide ranging. The history of hellebores, the origins, the genetics, and just about anything you wanted or needed to know. A serious book and written from the heart. Their Hellebore Open House weekends are fun. Hundreds of hellebores blooming and people sometimes are in line before the doors open so they can get rarer colors. And then have coffee and cookies! Yayyy hellebores!
Thank you, Mary Jane. I may have picked up the hellebore bug while writing the story. Clearly, I’ve been missing out on a lot, and agree with you wholeheartedly about the book. If I can get off my lazy ass next year, we might pile in the car for a road trip to Pine Knot for their Hellebore Open House. Maybe see you there!
Would love to see you!