When I joined the horticulture industry here in the UK several years ago I hadn’t appreciated that I would take my place not only in the wider community of gardeners but also in a new generation of gardeners following gardeners that went before me. On so many occasions other gardeners have recognised me as one of their number; I sometimes think I can spot a fellow gardener in the crowd but I’m always too scared to approach just in case I get it wrong.
People have dedicated themselves to the craft of gardening for centuries. Wherever the well-heeled have wanted to beautify their land there have been professional gardeners. While much of Europe was still defecating out of windows and baiting bears, the gardeners of Japan were developing a very rich cultural heritage of ornamental gardening around temples, palaces and private homes. The 11th century Sakutakei is likely to be the oldest garden planning text around, and its contents clearly suggest that the art and craft of creating sophisticated gardens was well established at the time.

A Japanese cedar growing in the UK
European ornamental gardening developed so gently over the centuries that it’s hard to define where it began here. As fortunes were made and people became less directly tied to the land for the basics of sustenance, outdoor spaces could be developed for purely ornamental purposes. Palaces and country estates built their great gardens, some of which survive in their original form today while many others have been lost to changes of fashion and fortune. History remembers the people who paid for these gardens, not the people who actually did the work.

The person who bought these Lawson Cypresses probably didn’t actually plant them…
I find myself less drawn to the stories people who commissioned gardens, or even those who designed them, and more to the lives of the ordinary gardeners like me. For centuries men (and in more recent times women too) have been drawn to work with the soil. Many came to gardening because gardening was the only career choice, while others will have spilled over from agriculture. A number will have started gardening because their father, and even grandfather too, had been a gardener.
Gardening is a noble craft. We get bogged down in lambasting and tutting at environmentally insensitive and dubious practices; at its most fundamental gardening is about making the world a better place, if only for your employer. The act of nurturing plants for food or for pleasure is a kindly one, and the best gardeners will always have been those with kind souls. When I look at the efforts that went into creating the big old gardens I visit today, I cannot help but marvel at the work of my horticultural forebears. History has largely forgotten their names- even the names of the Head Gardeners in most cases- but the legacy of the ordinary gardener lives on in every tree-lined avenue and in every towering specimen.

Productive walled garden, Knightshayes, Devon, UK
Nowhere is this legacy more visceral to me than in a walled garden.
In a large estate the walled garden was one of three hubs, alongside the estate workshops and the house itself. High walls protected crops from strong winds, deer and rabbits. In some cases the produce fed just the house, but in others the walled garden provided fruits and vegetables for the wider estate too. As 19th century horticulture became more sophisticated and materials became cheaper, so glasshouses built for peaches, grapes and other sensitive luxuries became more widespread. Pineapple pits used the heat given off by rotting manure to warm what was essentially a technically advanced cold frame; to my knowledge nobody is growing their own pineapples here now, despite the relative simplicity of the technology.

A neglected and battered grape house
Old walled gardens are haunted by the benign spirits of the gardeners who tended them. Gardening as an occupation is a spiritual affair; the gardeners who went before tended the earth and their plants with the same love that gardeners do now. Entering a walled garden it’s especially easy to imagine the space laid out and well tended. Labour was cheap in those days, so a small army of gardeners tending crops was fairly common. It was cheaper and less trouble to grow your own fresh food than to rely on far-off markets.
It saddens me to see a walled garden in a state of disrepair. After the Great War a lot of the gardeners who came back didn’t return to the gardens they had tended; after years of mud and dirt who could blame them? The economic woes of the 1920s and the increased industrialisation of agriculture in the 1930s, followed by another war, pretty much brought about the demise of the productive walled garden. Many limped on in a much reduced sense, some were demolished or abandoned, and others were turned into commercial market gardens.

A once-productive walled garden
Gardening itself underwent enormous changes during the 20th century. I came across a snippet in The Gardener’s Chronicle magazine in the early 1950s talking about the great labour-saving technologies that were revolutionising gardening; petrol (gasoline) lawnmowers were a huge revolution on their own. Technology meant that you could achieve greater results with fewer gardeners, although it’s debatable whether the technology drove the decline in gardeners or the declining number of gardeners drove the development of technologies. It doesn’t really matter.
What’s clear is that the old world of the apprentices, journeymen and whiskered Head Gardeners are long gone. Today’s gardeners are multi-talented, and machinery allows one gardener to achieve what would have taken several gardeners before.

This used to open the greenhouse vents, but the greenhouse is long gone
Yet as I found myself walking around a neglected walled garden I fancied that I could sense the old life of the place. Little hints of now-absent buildings littered the walls, telling their own story of neglect and demolition in the past. Mown grass covered the space where crops should have been, but most telling was the attempt to repurpose old borders for ornamental plants. It was as though the last remnants of the garden’s spirit were desperately holding on.

The old water trough
Of course I’m silly; the men who tended this garden have returned to the soil themselves. Yet the very bricks that bore testament to their hard work at the garden’s zenith seem ready to tell stories of what went before.
Our world is always changing but there will always be gardeners; I wonder if, one day, a gardener like me will look at something I’ve done and wonder about me?
You are so right. I have often complained about how guide books and histories of our great cathedrals and churches were built by so and so. So and so is always the person who ordered or paid for the construction, not the person who sweated over it.
Isn’t this what is still happening in gardens too, as we more often (in the UK) refer to the designers and owners of gardens than the gardeners?
While the ‘greats’ always seem to get their names in the history books, the world is actually built by ordinary people. Their contribution forms that all-important social history.
As for the present day, I am aware of people who openly claim to be sole gardeners creating gardens themselves while actually full time gardeners behind them. Personally I think recognising the contributions of others shows great leadership and is the mark of true talent, but I’m neither a big-name designer nor a TV personality.
Loved your piece on the traces working people leave behind them.
It’s always interesting to see these things in a museum but it’s much more meaningful to see them in their original places, as they were once used..
I agree completely. Thank you for reading.
Thoughtful reflections on gardeners of the past, Ben. Thank you for reminding us of our history and how the work actually got done in times past.
Thank you very much for reading.
Unfortunately, this is the way of the world where the wealthy are remembered not the people who actually accomplished something. I love the stories behind these old gardens and the techniques used to produce unlikely crops such as pineapples and citrus. One of my favourite reads is “the Lost Gardens of Heligon’ because of the history unearthed. When all is said and done your name might not be remembered but everything you accomplished will be. To me that’s a pretty good legacy.
You might enjoy reading “The Sakura Obsession” by Naoko Abe. It is the story of Collingwood Ingram and how he saved Japanese cherry trees, the history of the Japanese Cherry tree and an Englishman’s passion. Vintage Books, 2019.
Enjoy
You’re not at all silly for writing about and remembering those who made the gardens. It’s a beautiful sentiment. Who knows, maybe the “ghosts” of those workers could feel your interest and devotion to the old places. If not, then it’s still a lovely tribute to them however nameless they are now. Thanks for showing sensitivity to the past. We will all be there someday.
It would be nice to think so…
What a lovely tribute to the gardeners who’ve come before us! And I have very fond memories of the semi-neglected walled garden off the main house at a school I went to in England many years ago; to this child of modern-day California, it definitely felt haunted by those who had gone there before, in a good way. Filled with overgrown roses, herbs and a small patch of lawn, it also had a time-worn covered gazebo at one end, creating a perfect “hideout” for truant teenagers to hang out. Walls around a garden make everything feel intimate and familiar, somehow. Thanks for awaking those memories!
It’s funny how walled gardens have an impact; I was approached by someone this week who used to hide out in a walled garden when they were younger and had fond memories of it.
Oh how I loved reading this, Ben; thank you! To me, the best thing about old gardens and old plants are the stories behind them, which inevitably leads to fun and interesting, and often times inspiring, stories of the people who cultivated/grew them. Keep digging and sharing.
Beautifully written, Ben! A lovely tribute to the unseen gardeners who shaped these spaces.