I’ll admit it’s humbling to reread this post from 2018 in which I defended Periwinkle (Vinca minor) when it’s grown where it can’t do any harm. An example is in this spot surrounded by cement and asphalt at the edge of my parking lot. It can’t climb trees and it can’t be spread by birds, so in this spot, what’s the harm?
Which I still stand by. The part I want to take back is proclaiming it harmless around other perennials because in my Maryland gardens it had underperformed as a groundcover. So I didn’t worry about the springs of it that were existing in my new back garden, figuring it was better than bare ground and wasn’t hurting anything.
Until I noticed that the perennials I’d planted near it were failing and I wondered why. Coreopsis, Coneflower and Penstemon all dying off! But you already know what was doing just great there – the Periwinkle. One large, robust patch got my attention and I finally noticed the once-timid groundcover had been taking its vitamins. Or climate change had given it the boost it needed in my garden – whatever! Among the groundcovers I planted and want to thrive in this border are now signs of Periwinkle. Here it’s slowly but surely out-competing the Sedum takesimense and groundcover Comfrey by strangling them at the ground level. The soil is almost covered with its stems, enough to strangle neighboring perennials and maybe even some short shrubs.
A Month’s Work
I’d taken my eye off the Periwinkle ball for so long (at least the four years since I wrote about its harmlessness in my garden) that when I looked around my tiny townhouse garden, it was now everywhere! I don’t know how that happens to a super-seasoned gardener like myself who walks her garden daily with what she assumed was a keen eye, but it happened.
So my new newest obsession, and a very satisfying one, is removing the damn stuff. After almost a month of diligent, grubby work on my knees, filling this tip bag and other containers five times, making five trips to the yard-waste dump, it’s still not all gone but at least now I’m on high alert. Just like poison ivy, it’s a dangerous weed that stands out to my perusing eye.
Periwinkle roots aren’t so deep that they’re difficult to remove but simply pulling won’t do the job – a weeding KNIFE (also known as a Japanese hori-kori knife) is my favorite tool for the job. I just ordered a second one as back-up – because of my sad history of losing tools. Probably by dropping them in my tip bags.
Periwinkle roots aren’t so deep that they’re difficult to remove but simply pulling won’t do the job – a weeding KNIFE (also known as a Japanese hori-kori knife) is my favorite tool for the job. I just ordered a second one as back-up – because of my sad history of losing tools. Probably by dropping them in my tip bags.
Time to Rearrange the Borders!
With soil cleared of the now-hated groundcover, I have more room for flowering plants – yay! Like the couple of dozen that Rant commenters recommended last week (to this post) for attracting pollinators. I asked for plants that do well in pots but after researching the plants you all love, I’m going to need more space, including in the ground.
Sigh. I have to get serious about ripping out all the periwinkle that has invaded one of my flowerbeds. It was planted many years ago by a former owner as a groundcover under azaleas, where it is still welcome, but I got complacent about it and let it expand. Like you, I underestimated it!
I did my Masters thesis on whether vinca minor was suppressing biodiversity in a 40-acre plot of old-growth forest in Illinois. What do you think the data showed with statistical reliability?
At least I’m not alone in dropping tools in the compost bins 🙂
Keep fighting the good fight!
It is serious competition for trees! The roots that supply most trees with water and nutrients are in the top 6 – 8″ of the soil profile. Where are periwinkle roots? In the top 6 – 8″. The runners are notorious for running through the fine roots of azaleas. Again very heavy competition! It has no place in our gardens.
Ack, I’d better pull it out there too!
No periwinkle, but I am in the process of wiping out the Pachysandra!
My two favorite ground covers! Except that I wish I had not put the periwinkle against the house or the fence or under a tree, because I do not like it to climb. I’ve adopted my mother’s strategy for groundcovers, which is to plant 2-3 of them and let them battle it out. Along my hell strip, pachysandra is winning over periwinkle.
Yup! It’s amazing that you wrote this because I am in the process of digging the damn stuff out. It steals nutrients, crawls over plants that are trying to get started, and keeps them from getting light. “Out damn spot!!” .
none of you have tackled the BIG ONE; invasive bamboo. I am in the process of digging/hacking out as many rhizomes as is humanly possible. If anyone tells you herbicides or black plastic or mowingIn will do it in, they don’t know what they are talking about. In a yard that is too small for heavy equipment this is 100% hand labor. mid-south (Kentucky)
At least it’s in your yard. We get bamboo coming from a neighbor’s yard, so we can only pull what’s on our side of the fence.
I planted vinca minor in my front yard back in the late 70’s and for 35 years or so it did nothing much. Then one year it turned huge and invasive. It was in the pathway to my irrigation spigot and the vines would trip me. Dangerous. I ended up spraying it to kill it. Didn’t get it all and it’s still on the fence line on my neighbors side, so still defending the territory all these years later.
Yikes! Same here, planted vinca minor in the early 90’s under a Magnolia, it came down in a snow storm, but vinca persisted. Pulled like crazy and put in perennials and guess what’s back? Too bad the deer won’t eat it, as they are eating Lily of the Valley in another bed used as ground cover years ago.
Houttuynia cordata for me Susan. Came in on a friend’s rose and I wasn’t diligent about pulling every scrap of it early on. Now it’s a on-my-knees war with a rhizotomous root system that is very difficult to grub out. – MW
Let’s hear it for artemisia and lamb’s ear. Neither of those is famous for invasiveness, but l live in the mountains of NC, and we get more annual rain than Seattle. Everything (mostly) thrives. I planted a small clump of lamb’s ear about 8 years ago. Realized a couple of years later that it was a MISTAKE and pulled it out wherever it had jumped to. Uh, no, it still makes sly appearances many yards from the original plantings. How does that happen?
The artemisia was a bear to pull out, big tough stems, but so far it is staying gone….
But the true curse some wicked person put upon me is bermuda grass, which came in with some “free” mulch. I do not spray chemicals ordinarily, but l’m about to attack the bermuda grass with rub-on glycophosphate. (Roundup).
Beast of burden-inherited vinca major in the original garden patch out back when we bought our home 30 some years ago. The patch has somehow spread to the front boulevard garden and we live on a rock in Nanaimo BC Canada…the “beast” is now everywhere and laying in wait to “trip me up”…already spent oodles of $$ at the chiropractor’s and trips to the emergency ward for “slipped discs” and pulled muscles over the years. What artillery is left to use? I try to grow everything organically or at least pesticide free,but will admit to trying roundup once 29 years ago and yet the “beast” still prospers.Hands up I surrender!
Vinca is in so many commercial landscapes in N. Texas, but it suffers from our heat and soils and never looks good here. A native groundcover that I enjoy, but sometimes struggle to keep up with is Frog Fruit. It isn’t hard to pull, but it has tentacles that never stop reaching out to conquer new ground. Every gardener should have a strong sharp Hori Hori knife, but if you have one you love, mind your fingers and be sure to put a bit of fluorescent tape or paint on it to help you find it when you lay it down somewhere-Japanese steel is $$$.
I planted it in what was an empty area on the east side of my north Texas garden. It unfortunately did not struggle but thrived. Took me 3 years to get rid of it (mostly). Finally planted large vigorous Texas tough plants that outcompeted it.
We have all dumped our hori hori in the yard waste or compost and then had to go searching! Likewise, we have all planted or accidentally obtained a groundcover and then regretted it. I triumphed over chameleon plant after two years of hard work; luckily I haven’t had to struggle with vinca. Keep up the good fight everybody!