Last weekend a friend and I happened upon a neighborhood yard sale filled with all the stuff my kids will be flogging when my husband and I permanently exit stage left. My eye was caught by an array of good garden tools lined up against a wall – so we paused our plans, stopped the car and nosed around. A few minutes later we were in long conversation with the daughter of the couple who had recently died within a year of one another; and twenty minutes later, our hearts felt full.

Garden collections – how do they even happen?
Yet theirs was not an extraordinary story. No one would have bought the rights or ghost written the details to create New York Times Best Seller List fodder. It was entirely and beautifully ordinary; and there is no need to share it as I wouldn’t do justice to the simplicity of her expressions, pauses, and laughter as she talked about her parents while standing in the midst of their lives spread out at her feet.
It was the Everyman quality of that history that resonated with me as I picked through boxes of garden tools and board games and thought about my own boxes of garden tools and board games sitting at home in various states of use and neglect.
Lives led, now finished. Stuff left, now sold. Hundreds of dollars’ worth of something or other offered for ten dollars, and ten dollars’ worth of something else for a quarter.

Even the most expensive, curated objects at a garden center eventually become ‘stuff’ within a year of coming home.
I hesitate to start this paragraph with “As a gardener” because I could just as soon start it with “As a woman… As a mother…. As a wife… As a daughter…. As a human being…” All identities suddenly and deeply felt the tenuous, temporary connection that exists between Us and Our Stuff.
But it was the gardener that sustained the gut-punch. Whilst everyone needs plates and silverware and (during a small period in their twenties) shot glasses, very few have use for a good pair of pruners.
And for those of us who garden, so much of what we acquire to create that garden is extremely fragile — occupying a unique spot in our consciousness. Just ours. So much of it looks like junk to other people – the useful bit of wire, the bag of zip-ties, the multi-year tomato cages, the endlessly reused black plastic pots. I once found an eight-inch piece of cord carefully coiled into an Altoid tin in my father’s glove compartment – his reasons for keeping such a treasure lost to the ether.
The plastic pots that my eyes scanned and rejected at that sale were shoved under a table – no doubt bound for the landfill. How much importance did they have to their owner? Perhaps no more regard than I gave them, but perhaps they were as significant as the ugly pink plastic pot I do not throw away because my mother handed it to me two decades ago filled with pothos – and then waved goodbye to a daughter, son-in-law and baby grandchild bound for a new life 2,748 miles away. No one will remember that moment or that pot as they are clearing up a cluttered shed and wondering why mom owned a pink pot when she hated the color pink.

No one will know – or care – that this rusted wheelbarrow was wrestled from behind an apartment complex in Annapolis 15 years ago – discarded by its first (?) owner, treasured by its new one.
Treasures metamorphizing into trash. And that’s not even mentioning the plants to which most normal people would attach no value at all, and if pressed, perhaps describe as “green.”
Only a handful will ask to dig a special plant – most likely for memory’s sake. Probably it will be common. Ironically it will bloom pink. Will my ghost hover around them I wonder – trying desperately to draw attention to the variegated rohdea and sighing mournfully when they dig the hydrangea instead?
“Did she really devote her life to this?” they will ask my daughter as they offer a dollar for a pot I drove to Baltimore in a rickety truck with no air conditioning in order to source – fragments of a Taco Bell lunch balanced precariously on my lap, the thrill of acquisition across my face.
“You say she was out here every day?” they will say to my son as they sort through thousands of garden books looking for one filled with glossy pictures, ignoring beloved volumes of essays with broken bindings and ex-library stamps. Will the wisdom of Mitchell, Lawrence, Lloyd and Lacy end up at the thrift store next to eight copies of the 63rd edition of Better Homes and Gardens’ plaid cookbook, or will another young upthrusting gardener ask to take the lot for ten dollars? I can hope.
How important it all is to me, but how little importance it has in the end. It is connection with friends, family and other human beings that makes this life resonate beyond the tiny parameters one is given to live it.

Quite frankly, there are objects that belong at a yard sale.
I drove home on Saturday knowing that it is better to hope that my children disconnect from all these precious things of mine – secure in the connection they had with me. It is better to hope that my daughter will, like the woman I met that day, feel called to share a laugh with a stranger as she relates the story of her very ordinary, curiously obsessed mother, her garden-bemused father, and a childhood marked by plants and indentured servitude.
I hope she laughs right up until that stranger offers her a quarter for a pair of Felcos. I didn’t raise a fool.
Love this!!!
About calling plants “green”. What slays me is plant people themselves referring to plants as “plant material”. Even “number of plant materials “ when one word wd have sufficed.
Ok I’m off on a rant here. Sorry ! But to continue..,
To me “plant material” sd b confined to yard waste.
I’m guilty as charged on that one in my last book – and probably elsewhere here and there. I tend to use it when talking about plants in bulk or in landscaping applications. I’m transgressing the manifesto I know! – MW
“Plant people”…..being a landscape designer allowed me a most satisfying life full of sweat and hard work….but also a good, honest living…and thru being gracious, put up an online friend who gave me a stock tip in 1998 to buy 1,000 shares of some small company destined to become the Walmart of the internet….those 1,000 shares of Amazon at 19.50/share grew to 47 million dollars….talk about Jack and the Beanstalk!!
This made me cry and smile at the same time! I have already pointed out the value of my Felcos to my daughters. They will have to draw straws for them.
Made me tear up too…been wondering lately what happens to all of “this?” I carry my mother’s rooting and planting gene strongly in me, but not seeing it in the offspring. Just like “they don’t want your brown furniture” am afraid they will not want my “green stuff” either. So we do it for us, for ourselves. What a wonderful rant, thank you.
You can never tell which direction your children will go. My two daughters showed no particular interest in my gardens. That is, until they got homes of their own and they suddenly became avid gardeners.
Being the only member of my household who ‘cares’ about anything green and living I too have had thoughts about what will happen to this beautiful garden I have put so much sweat, money and labour into developing? Probably a good thing I will be long gone and never have to find out. There is always hope a like-minded gardener will carry on.
Marianne, that was beautifully written, as always. And very poignant to me as I head into my 78th year. I’m starting a new “garden” on my property — Wildflower Woods (yes, I am naming it) — which will have only native plants, because, inspired by Doug Tallamy, I am trying to create a Homegrown National Park. I will probably not see its maturity, but I hope it will survive any new homeowners and quietly perform its ecological services. In the meantime, I will instruct children and grandchildren on the value of Felcos! (Who but gardeners would know what the heck we’re talking about!)
‘
M.,
Your essay regarding the trash/treasure aspect is among the best writing, garden or otherwise, that I have come across. Ever. It was (is) touching and real (70-something parent here). I’m passing it along to Da Missus for her bemusement and inevitable wistfulness.
When the day comes for someone to publish the “Wilburn Collection”, this piece will be front and center. (And, Henry, in his Heaven, is smiling at you.)
J.
What John said about the “Wilburn Collection.” I look forward to reading it! This was lovely and interesting and poignant, and I now feel the need to tag my signed Elizabeth Lawrence books to note to whomever has to dispose of my garden estate, “These are valuable, to someone!” What else? Ah yes, there is the hoe collection. Should they sell it off piece by piece or see what they can get for the whole lot. And will they realize that stack of 4-inch clay pots belonged to my dad? Or care? Regardless, I will keep acquiring what I love and hope when my estate goes up for sale, a gardener or two stop by and feel like they’ve hit the jackpot of gardening.
Marianne,
This piece really struck home with me. In my 81st year such considerations are very close to home. I am reminded of an entry by Len Geiger in the blog “Married with Plants” stating that a garden in a “generational thing” to be bulldozed by developers after the gardener is gone.
One of my daughters sent me a subscription to StoryWorth which requires me to write an essay on a new question each week. It has been a trip down memory lane for me and raised some of these same thoughts.
Bless you for your talented writing. I always look forward to your posts.
Oh Marianne, I adore your writing. Thank you so much for taking us along on this one. So much resonates, I cannot pick a favorite part. This is what writing is supposed to do.
Wow, just wow. So beautifully written. Is that a tear welling up, I wonder.
What a wonderful piece. I will forward a link of this rant to my oldest daughter whose gardening gene is slow to germinate. She likes plants, but has little free time. There is so much I identify with. Will my daughter know that several of the rocks in my garden were ones I collected when I was six? There are many stories behind so many of my gardening things. Too many to tell. Thank you for writing this.
*sigh*
Smiling through misty eyes. I feel this intensely, with a tightness in my chest because I am the estate sale shopper of garden things. And mine will some day be the gardener’s estate being sold. I wonder at what my children will choose to retain, and what they will release. My daughter will know the value of the odd things – “muse it up, wear it out, make it do, or do without” is her very heartfelt motto. Unlikely she will want my potted plants, but the plant ties that have been used for ages and just don’t wear out – she’ll probably want those. And the pruners and loppers. She’s as practical as her father. My son, though … he does not care for gardening so I can see he’ll take one of my empty pots and use it to stash bills or keys or chargers. Or the rocks I pick up from every trip I take and leave lying around the garden beds. He’s more sentimental than his sister. I can see he’d keep my botanical Latin book because it’s language and history wrapped together. They may argue over which tea book goes with whom.
So true. How deeply meaningful objects are when associated with people, places and history and how utterly lacking in meaning and value they can be untethered from these moorings. My husband and I were grad students for so long that we didn’t accumulate much and gladly accepted all the things our parents gave in their lifetime or left to us. It is a way of living with them. How wise to hope that one’s offspring will be secure in their bonds with their parents not to cling to their belongings. And how sad it was to witness one grandparent who worked hard to afford the few bits of finery and luxury she had, only to have to shed them, at best to indifferent progeny, at worst to the dumpster, and then to live another 10 years wondering what happened to them.
Another great post, Marianne! This one causes me to take a hard look at the jetsam and flotsam that accumulates in various parts of my yard, wondering how it got there.
Lovely post . I love growing chiles and herbs and greens and tomatillos. I don’t have room on our tiny HOA controlled lot to grow much else edible so happily support our local farmers by buying their produce and expertise. I love my garden and am working to convert our landscaper grade crap yard to one that can help sustain wildlife. I skew hard toward native plants but love hydrangeas and daylilies and hostas, so tuck those in too. I’ve locked our landscaping company out and banned most chemicals, but will combat fire ants with whatever it takes. We eat local to the extent possible most of the time, but I had things I could not source at the farmers’ markets delivered by Amazon/WF for a solid COVID year. We do what we can do. I choose to view it as maintaining balance.
LOL and this comment was on an earlier post. The one above is lovely too. 🙂
What a lovely article. This is a subject I think about more and more as I approach my eightieth year. Everyone loves the gardens but many say “so much work” when I have never “worked” a day in the gardens. I am presently aiming for 85 as the year when the home and gardens might be sold to a gardener. Maybe they will let me visit…
Lovely rant offering great reasons to live in the moment.
Crying, laughing, and crying some more. I appreciate your words, sentiment and humility. We all end up as landfill. I have that bit of twine too.
Marianne, you’re too young for thoughts about what tools and books of yours will be left behind at the end! I’ve got 20 years on you and gave away a car load of garden books a few weeks ago and trust they are in good hands. I held onto Lawrence, Mitchell, Lacy, Lloyd and a few others I wanted to keep around for good company. I know one of our kids will have the good sense to hang on to my beloved Dutch scuffle hoe. But heaven knows who will tend the garden, if at all, after Rose and I are gone. Oh, I’ve made this sound so dreary, when actually it has been an extraordinary, life-affirming, post covid lockdown spring. Thank you for a great essay.
Great post. Very poignant after you’ve emptied your parent’s home.
It may cheer you to know that I daily use a half length, 2B pencil with a label wrapped round it saying ‘LABEL PENCIL. POTTING SHED. My Dad’s.
This reminded me so much of my father; a lifelong gardener, a mender of broken things, and a keeper-of-things-that-may-be-useful. After he died, it was with great care that I collected a few choice plants to take to my own garden. The dense clump of Trillium grandiflorum, especially. Even though I carefully cleaned it in dormancy, three years after relocating it I discovered goutweed had hidden itself among the roots of that treasure. Dad always did save every seedling and sprout just in case his kids might need some plants for their yard. So this fits his MO to a t. Thanks for the nostalgia trip!
Beautiful & true, as the best writing always is.
This made me laugh, smile and cry all at the same time. What will happen to my grandmother galvanized watering can with her handwritting African Violets Only written on it?
What a great ending!
Loved reading this over my morning tea. Traveling for a pot really resonates with me after cajoling my husband
and son-in-law to travel 45 minutes away on Mother’s Day to pick up a concrete pot with a Japanese Maple in it that took four men to lift onto the pick-up truck, but a steal at $20!
First of all, thank you for gifting such an article. I have read your article carefully floating in the sea of imagination. I found a beautiful analogy of enjoying life through storytelling. The landscapes used in the middle of the essay made my mind more mesmerized.