Books, Everybody's a Critic

The good and the bad from the Brits

One of my favorite poisonous natives (photo by Martha Baskin)

One of my favorite poisonous natives (photo by Martha Baskin)

Many of us have a love/hate affair with gardening advice and essays that come from across the Atlantic.  There is always love, of course, for this mothership of great estate gardens, internationally known garden events, and giants of gardening design and literature like  Gertrude Jekyll, Christopher Lloyd, Dan Pearson, and so many others. The hate, sad to say, is mostly from jealousy; though gardening is not as popular as it was across the pond, it still seems much more in the mainstream, with more and better periodicals and even some decent TV programs. And there’s also a little zone envy for a climate that allows the gardener to work pretty much year-round, without getting scorched or frozen.

Sooner or later, most of us will make the pilgrimage to see the great English gardens—I saw much of Somerset ten years ago and long to return to visit other hot spots. Until that time, however, I’ve got some big coffee table books, and this compendium of writing from the Telegraph, Of Rhubarb and Roses: The Telegraph Book of the Garden. It was sent last December and I’m just now getting to it.

51tgwJJTPBLThe Telegraph has been publishing gardening columns since the fifties. There are 18 thematic sections with charming quotes used as titles—There are at least four wrong ways to grow daffodils,” and “You do not expect to find innocence by the end of summer.” The writers are everyone you’d expect, from Vita Sackville-West to Sarah Raven to Beth Chatto, and many other familiar names (even an essay on snails by Germaine Greer).  The short essays are usually funny and opinionated, often eccentric, and entirely lack the generic blandness of most American newspaper gardening advice.

However,  I also have a love/hate affair with the Telegraph. True, it is a reliable source of garden-related matter, much of it quite good, as this book demonstrates. But a lot of the stuff I find there these days is just nuts, with the nuttiest articles being published on the topic of native plants. In Jane Milliman’s Ear to the Ground newsletter this week, she points to an article warning of the “deadly toxins” being spread by the UK’s current Grow Wild wildflower planting campaign. (Yes, many, many plants are toxic; this is why we don’t eat random plants unless we know they’re edible—and maybe not even then.) A few weeks back, I actually saw an article there claiming talk of protecting native species was “quasi-racist.”

In fact, you can usually count on finding sensationalist content in a lot of the Telegraph’s content these days. At least as far as gardening goes, I’d recommend keeping to the standard set by Of Rhubarb and Roses; I’m looking forward to whiling away the cold months with this one.

Posted by on September 8, 2014 at 8:45 am, in the category Books, Everybody's a Critic.
Comments are off for this post

6 responses to “The good and the bad from the Brits”

  1. Jane Scorer says:

    You won me over with that one fantastic sentence ‘You do not expect to find innocence by the end of summer’! Fantastic truth on so many levels!

  2. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve heard that native plant / racism angle; makes no sense to me. Hugh Raffles had a piece that was, well, interesting three years back: http://www.nytimes.com/2011/04/03/opinion/03Raffles.html

  3. tara dillard says:

    Seems old fashioned, unimportant. Difference between gardens across the Pond. Is either side of the Pond doing well?

    30 years in my garden, only the past 2 with chickens.

    It was a molten shift from having a garden of amusement to having a garden of stewardship.

    UGA agriculture school is visiting one of my gardens for a symposium next year. it is ornamental and agricultural and with heirloom livestock. Have studied landscape design deeply for decades and have discovered that ornamental horticulture & agriculture should not be segregated. Even if agriculture is for the sole benefit of pollinators & not human food production.

    Why is it legal to sell/buy/use NPK fertilizers? Toxic to groundwater, and the list goes on.

    So much off topic, but not. Adore Amy Stewart’s, the Drunken Botanist. Perhaps she will pull in many who would have never considered planting anything, ever. It’s a gimmick, but perhaps the perfect one to get more people into gardening ! Go Amy, can’t wait for your next title.

    Garden & Be Well, XO Tara

  4. Anne Wareham says:

    I suppose it may not be clear sometimes that Telegraph gardening may be simply reporting mad stuff from elsewhere in the UK press, but I think that may have been the case in the pieces you example.

    It certainly offers a range of articles and ideas that isn’t matched anywhere else in the print media in the UK – and it is also available online. Worth following on twitter I’d say, to pick up interesting writing.

    They even publish me, and that really is radical….

  5. David mcMullin says:

    Thank God for the Telegraph… it may be the last legitimate repository of all things garden.

  6. Tom Fischer says:

    The Telegraph has an absolutely stellar group of garden columnists, including the brilliant Tim Richardson, who for my money is the most incisive and thoughtful interpreter of what’s going on in the gardening world. If some of the other writers get a little loony once in a while, so what? It’s a small miracle nowadays when a U.S. newspaper has even one regular garden columnist, let alone seven.

  • Follow Garden Rant

    Follow Me on Pinterest RSS